HB Contracting Co.

How to compare deck estimates line by line

  • 2 min read

Compare two deck quotes by scope, materials, allowances, and unknowns so you can see what each contractor is actually pricing.

Two deck proposals shown side by side with rows for stairs, rails, and removal

Two estimates can describe the same backyard and come back with very different totals. One may include a new landing and railings. Another might assume the current footings can stay. Put the totals aside for a few minutes and compare the finished project each document describes. You’ll have better questions and a clearer sense of what the numbers buy.

Give both proposals the same starting point

On a sheet of paper, write the size of the deck, intended layout, surface material, stairs, railings, and any cover or changes to the patio. Put a check next to each item mentioned in each bid. When an item is called out in one and silent in the other, ask for clarification. “Rails included” is a start. A named product or allowance, the run it covers, and whether stair rails are included tell you more.

Look for the boundaries between trades

Check who removes the old deck, hauls it away, and handles related surfaces. If you want lighting or plan to change a door, ask which work is included and which is priced separately. Ask how permits and inspections are handled for your address. The entry that matters most is often between two jobs: where a new stair meets an old patio, or where a cover meets the house. These are good places for the scope to be specific.

Give surprises a place in the document

Existing conditions can be hard to judge before demolition. Ask which parts of the old deck the estimate assumes will be reused, what will be inspected after it is opened, and how work outside the proposal will be documented and approved. Find out what the contractor needs to revisit if you change materials. Knowing what’s provisional gives you room to decide without trying to predict everything behind the old boards.

Give allowances the same treatment

Suppose both bids allow for a railing and one names a specific system while the other gives you a budget to shop within. Ask what price and labor assumptions sit behind the allowance, and how the final selection would change the total. Do the same for stairs, board finishes, and other choices you haven’t made. You may find that the difference between the two estimates is smaller once you ask for the same finished result.

Ask for one short follow-up

Send each contractor the same two or three questions. Put the answers next to the original estimate. If one scope is easier to understand, note whether that clarity addresses your highest priorities. If you’re still gathering information, the deck estimate preparation guide explains what to have on hand. Contact HB Contracting Co. to discuss a free estimate for your deck or patio.

Keep reading

All articles

Have a project in mind?

Bring your ideas and a few photos of the space. Estimates are free.